Search This Blog

Monday, September 17, 2018

On Durand's Curse




“When two elephants fight, it is the grass that suffers”  - Kenyan Proverb

‘Durand’s Curse’ by Rajiv Dogra details the events and circumstances leading to the fateful agreement of 12th November, 1893CE when the Durand’s Line separating the present day Afghanistan and Pakistan came into existence. It also encompasses a comprehensive and contemporary view of present day Afghanistan, lamenting the monumental injustice meted to Afghans, especially the Pathans.
 
In mid 20eth Century, as many countries across Asia, Africa and South America emerged Independent from the clutches of Colonialism, lines were arbitrarily drawn by few powerful men, separating and creating nations. Sykes-Picot, Radcliff are to name among a few. But, perhaps the most chaotic and arbitrary one was the ‘Durand’s Line’. In a crazy and concocted ‘Great Game’, Afghanistan was envisioned as a buffer zone separating British India from Tsarist Russia rather than an Independent country.

Spooked by unsubstantiated claims of Russian Invasion of India, the British (then East India Company) replaced the immensely popular King of Afghanistan, Dost Mohammad Khan with Shuja Shah. However, the fiercely independent Afghans struck back, and what followed for the next century was an era of trickery and bloodshed. After Partition of India, Afghanistan’s position went from bad to worse, as vouched by it’s recent history. A disastrous civil war, ambitious neighbors and changing geopolitical scenario means that another ‘Great Game’ is at play!

It is a must read for anyone interested in the Indo-Afghan Foreign affairs/Afghanistan/Geopolitics of Asia.

Book – Durand’s Curse by Rajiv Dogra (English)

Wednesday, September 12, 2018

Badshah Khan





“But you are deserting us now, and throwing us to the wolves.”                 
- Khan Abdul Ghaffar Khan admonishing members of the Congress Working Committee after they agreed for the partition of India. (c.1946)

‘My Life and Struggle’ is the autobiography of Khan Abdul Ghaffar Khan, regarded as ‘Fakhr-e-Afghan’ (Pride of Afghans) and ‘Badshah Khan’ (Emperor among Khans), with a foreword by Jayaprakash Narayan. The Indian freedom struggle, especially the Gandhian Phase attracted people from all walks of life and Badshah Khan was the most famous leader from the North West (the then NWFP). Born in a rich Pathan family, he stood out for his broad-mindedness and patience. He was instrumental in establishing the organization - ‘Khudai Khitmatgars’(Servants of God, more popular as ‘Red Shirts’). He was later awarded the Bharat Ratna. Those were the facts that we all know.
But, he was a man whose long & cruel years in imprisionment are only marked by respect and civility towards his British Captors. During the Civil Disobedience movement, when the Empire struck back in Peshawar, it was his Khudai Khitmatgars who paid with their blood. And his quest for freedom and self-determination led him only to prison, first as a guest of the British Empire, and then under the new nation of Pakistan. When the Partition of India became imminent, all his concerns were swept under the carpet, and a much respected leader was maligned for his ‘Pakistan or Pakhtunistan’ remarks. 

Being an autobiography, the book is straight forward; fact based and sporadically sketches lots of people who are in awe as well as in disgust of the Badshah Khan.

By the time of his death, there was no peace in South Asia. India and Pakistan were involved in a conflict over Siachen Glacier. And his beloved people, the Pathans (mostly in Afghanistan and Pakistan) were drawn into a civil war which never stopped and no one understood.

When he was old, he wandered and spoke in Afghanistan, as the country was getting torn to pieces. But, it was a tribute to the man that when he passed away, the Afghan Civil War had a temporary truce for 3 days so that the people can pay their respects to their beloved ‘Badshah Khan’.
 
If only the partition of India and Pakistan never took place, Or
If only the partition place in a much humane and leisurely way, with the NWFP province getting more provincial autonomy, Or
If only the Afghans had a leader like the Badshah Khan whose tolerance could outwit and outgun the murderous rage of the Taliban…..
If Only.

Book - My Life and Struggle - Autobiography of Khan Abdul Ghaffar Khan with foreword by Jayaprakash Narayan